Bryan Wang writes: In ID 21 and ID 20. There are three places talking about the data to be included in the authenticator computation, and one of them has to be corrected. Binding Update * Parameters: + HMAC_SHA1 (Kbm, (care-of address | CN address | BU)) Binding Acknowledgement * Parameters: + HMAC_SHA1 (Kbm, (care-of address | CN address | BA)) 6.2.7 Binding Authorization Data Mobility Data = care-of address | final dest | Mobility Header Data Authenticator = First (96, HMAC_SHA1 (Kbm, Mobility Data)) Which one? ------------------------ Jari Arkko responds to Bryan Wang: I have now aligned the formulas, as well as clarified that "final dest" is the CN address, not the MN address (was unclear for BAs). See http://www.piuha.net/~jarkko/publications/mipv6/drafts/mobilev6.html#rr-cnbind http://www.piuha.net/~jarkko/publications/mipv6/drafts/mobilev6.html#auth-option ------------------------ ------------------------ ------------------------